ATR Trailing Stop EA updated to version 1.06 to introduce an MT5 version and fix working with multiple symbols.
ATR Trailing Stop EA
- Thread starter Enivid
- Start date
- Watchers 10
The EA has been updated to version 1.07 to fix some bugs that could cause incorrect trailing stop application.
I try in MT5 version on Real Account of FBS that show error
Wrong position modification request: -1283766019 in XRPUSD at SL = 0.56196, TP = 0.0
SO , i checked this ticket order is not 1283766019 I think ea not catch the ticket number on real account
But , EA still work on demo account with out any error
I need to ask you that the ticket number on real account and demo account are different right? or EA problem , thank
Wrong position modification request: -1283766019 in XRPUSD at SL = 0.56196, TP = 0.0
SO , i checked this ticket order is not 1283766019 I think ea not catch the ticket number on real account
But , EA still work on demo account with out any error
I need to ask you that the ticket number on real account and demo account are different right? or EA problem , thank
Please try the attached version. I think the issue isn't in real vs. demo. It looks like the ticker number is so large it doesn't fit into an normal integer variable, so an unsigned long integer should be used instead. Please let me know whether this fixed the problem, so I could update this for everyone. Thanks!
Attachments
i had Tried attachment version work on real and demo account with out any error , thank for good tool
ATR Trailing Stop EA updated to version 1.08 to fix the bug reported by @piranzamate and also some other minor errors.
Hi,
I downloaded your indicator and loaded it on MT4. When I activated the indicator, I placed a new trade to test it. The ATR Trailer indicator applied to my old positions as well, using the current price with my old trades. It did not account for the fact that the old trades cannot be filled with the new trade's ATR values. Consequently, the indicator set the same stop-loss for the old trades as the new trade I experimented with, unfortunately closing 2 of my old trades and causing a loss of $1464.75. I am not very happy about this. Please be careful. Perhaps I could have prevented it, but I could not apply the indicator only to new trades and did not anticipate this issue since the ATR values are not the same for a new trade today.
Best regards.
I downloaded your indicator and loaded it on MT4. When I activated the indicator, I placed a new trade to test it. The ATR Trailer indicator applied to my old positions as well, using the current price with my old trades. It did not account for the fact that the old trades cannot be filled with the new trade's ATR values. Consequently, the indicator set the same stop-loss for the old trades as the new trade I experimented with, unfortunately closing 2 of my old trades and causing a loss of $1464.75. I am not very happy about this. Please be careful. Perhaps I could have prevented it, but I could not apply the indicator only to new trades and did not anticipate this issue since the ATR values are not the same for a new trade today.
Best regards.
Could you please clarify which expert advisor are you talking about? Is it ATR Trailer or is it ATR Trailing Stop? They are two different EAs.
Sorry, but this doesn't clarify anything. There is no such thing as "Trailing stop, ATR indicator" on our website. We have only these two:
https://www.earnforex.com/metatrader-expert-advisors/atr-trailing-stop/
https://www.earnforex.com/metatrader-expert-advisors/ATR-Trailer/
Neither is an indicator.
If you want to avoid ATR Trailing Stop EA from applying to some of your trades, you can use its filtering options. For the trades on the same symbol, there's a magic number filter and a commentary filter. There's no trade age filter.
