XAUUSD

Mar 29, 2024
20
3
4
22
Judge me all you want but I have my reasons to doubt BTC could be a replacement for Gold as unstable as it is now. Especially considering how the whales control their drops and rises.
The same thing goes for gold, that's the point the mechanisms of both assets share some similarities but the potential for growth is just on another level with BTC.
 

Amadeus.V

Active Trader
Jul 7, 2023
106
12
34
31
I agree with your skepticism. Bitcoin's volatility and the influence of large holders, or "whales," can make it less stable compared to gold, which has a long history as a store of value and hedge against economic uncertainty. While Bitcoin has potential as a digital asset, its current instability and market manipulation by major players make it a less reliable replacement for gold in terms of stability and safety.

Thank you! Thank you for understanding my point of view! I don't hate cryptocurrencies, I find them very interesting but there are facts to be considers such as your statements.
But at the same time, I hate to admit it but, Gold is losing its title as the 'asset to hedge against inflation' due to it's price reaction to geopolitical events, and in some inflationary periods, Gold has underperformed.
lastly, I'd say IF indeed Gold is giving that title away, it wouldn't be BTC, it would be to stocks and real estate.
 

Zerologic

Trader
Jul 17, 2024
73
1
9
The price of gold is influenced by demand and supply factors, this correlates with the USD, usually if the USD weakens the price of gold rises, conversely if the USD strengthens gold may fall. But China also contributes to gold demand, China's accelerating economy could push up gold prices.
 

Amadeus.V

Active Trader
Jul 7, 2023
106
12
34
31
The price of gold is influenced by demand and supply factors, this correlates with the USD, usually if the USD weakens the price of gold rises, conversely if the USD strengthens gold may fall. But China also contributes to gold demand, China's accelerating economy could push up gold prices.
Can you elaborate on why would it push up gold prices? I'm talking about China's economy
 

Zerologic

Trader
Jul 17, 2024
73
1
9
True. I did quite recently read some news articles about it as gold reached AHT.
I am also amazed recently read the chart of gold already reached above $2500, it has already broken the $2400 zone. It is a record new ATH once again in 2024.
 
  • 👍
Reactions: Amadeus.V

Zerologic

Trader
Jul 17, 2024
73
1
9
Indeed. I truly believe that Gold is a beauty of an asset.
Gold has become a safe-haven asset amidst global uncertainty, perhaps when the world is threatened with World War 3, the price of gold might soar again, but gold is very volatile, sometimes profit-taking can bring the price down quite deeply.
 

Amadeus.V

Active Trader
Jul 7, 2023
106
12
34
31
Gold has become a safe-haven asset amidst global uncertainty, perhaps when the world is threatened with World War 3, the price of gold might soar again, but gold is very volatile, sometimes profit-taking can bring the price down quite deeply.
To be honest, even though it's not my thing but I believe WW III could have a direct on BTC more than it would have on Gold.
 

Zerologic

Trader
Jul 17, 2024
73
1
9
To be honest, even though it's not my thing but I believe WW III could have a direct on BTC more than it would have on Gold.
Perhaps, the price of Bitcoin is much higher than gold, now BTC has reached $64k, but gold may also rise higher, now it is above $2500.
 

Enivid

Administrator
Staff member
Nov 30, 2008
19,058
1,472
144
Odesa
www.earnforex.com
Perhaps, the price of Bitcoin is much higher than gold, now BTC has reached $64k, but gold may also rise higher, now it is above $2500.
Sorry, but that doesn't make much sense. The price of gold is determined per arbitrary unit of mass. If you switch from troy ounce to a metric ton, it becomes much more expensive than 1 BTC. You cannot draw any meaningful conclusions from such comparisons.
 
  • 👍
Reactions: Zerologic and Amadeus.V

Amadeus.V

Active Trader
Jul 7, 2023
106
12
34
31
Perhaps, the price of Bitcoin is much higher than gold, now BTC has reached $64k, but gold may also rise higher, now it is above $2500.
Sorry, but that doesn't make much sense. The price of gold is determined per arbitrary unit of mass. If you switch from troy ounce to a metric ton, it becomes much more expensive than 1 BTC. You cannot draw any meaningful conclusions from such comparisons.
Getting fact-checked by admins is tough.
Comparing two things that have different units of measurement is not meaningful at all.

That's as meaningless as Billy Carson saying "Hydrogen Frequency"!
 
  • 👍
Reactions: Zerologic

Zerologic

Trader
Jul 17, 2024
73
1
9
Sorry, but that doesn't make much sense. The price of gold is determined per arbitrary unit of mass. If you switch from troy ounce to a metric ton, it becomes much more expensive than 1 BTC. You cannot draw any meaningful conclusions from such comparisons.
Thank you for the correction, this has provided new enlightenment for me.
Gold is now likely to stay above $2500 but BTC is down at $58k
 

Amadeus.V

Active Trader
Jul 7, 2023
106
12
34
31
Thank you for the correction, this has provided new enlightenment for me.
Gold is now likely to stay above $2500 but BTC is down at $58k
Mate, Bitcoin is a coin that can be influenced by whales of the market. How can you trust an asset like that?
Gold, on the other hand, has so much liquidity that only geopolitical events that correlate to something that can be traced by news sources affect it.
 

Enivid

Administrator
Staff member
Nov 30, 2008
19,058
1,472
144
Odesa
www.earnforex.com
Mate, Bitcoin is a coin that can be influenced by whales of the market. How can you trust an asset like that?
Gold, on the other hand, has so much liquidity that only geopolitical events that correlate to something that can be traced by news sources affect it.
I'd argue that the influence of whales on the market is rather similar for BTC and gold. In BTC, the biggest influence is exercised by miners and governments. In gold, it's mostly central banks.
 
  • 👍
Reactions: Amadeus.V and Zerologic

Zerologic

Trader
Jul 17, 2024
73
1
9
I'd argue that the influence of whales on the market is rather similar for BTC and gold. In BTC, the biggest influence is exercised by miners and governments. In gold, it's mostly central banks.
Yes, I think so, the central bank uses gold as a reserve, but I also think that gold-importing countries such as China and India can also influence the gold market.
 

Amadeus.V

Active Trader
Jul 7, 2023
106
12
34
31
I'd argue that the influence of whales on the market is rather similar for BTC and gold. In BTC, the biggest influence is exercised by miners and governments. In gold, it's mostly central banks.
I completely agree with you mate, but the difference is that you can follow up on banks news and be prepared for certain situations. Can you be prepared for what the whales might do? Who are they? They could be anyone with huge amounts of capital in BTC, whether that is an individual or an organization. Then again that organization could be from an official governmental organization or a private organization. You see how much risk there is to it? I'm just being realistic mate.